Station 41
Steve Hutchinson
Age: 68 years old male
Examiner
Marking Scheme
Data Gathering and Diagnosis
- Ask about breathlessness – how breathless, how far can they walk, any breathlessness at rest and any associated wheeze.
- Ask if there is breathless when lying flat (orthopnoea) or waking at night gasping for air (PND – paroxysmal nocturnal dyspnoea), to rule out heart failure
- Ask about cough – if present, ask about sputum production (colour, quantity) and any blood in the sputum (haemoptysis)
- Ask about chest pain, palpitations, chest tightness (to consider possible angina or cardiac cause)
- Ask about fever or chills (to identify signs of infection)
- Ask about fatigue, weight loss, night sweats (to explore constitutional symptoms or malignancy)
- Ask about current inhaler use – how often he uses them and whether he is using the correct technique (to ensure inhalers are being used effectively as prescribed)
- Ask if he has ever been considered for home oxygen
- Ask about impact on daily life – washing, dressing, toileting, moving around the house, shopping, etc.
- Ask about the home situation – who lives at home, what support is available, how his wife is coping, and whether any carers are involved or if a social care needs assessment has been done.
- Ask how many exacerbations and hospital admission they’ve had in the past year and if they’ve needed antibiotics or steroids recently
- Ask about mood – whether he has been feeling low, anxious, or overwhelmed (especially important in patients with chronic disease or recent hospital admissions, as they are at higher risk of depression and emotional distress)
- Ask about other social and lifestyle history – including smoking history, alcohol use, and occupation
- Ask about flu, pneumococcal, and COVID vaccination status
- Ask whether there have been any discussions around ceilings of care, advance care planning, or DNACPR.
- Make a diagnosis of Advanced (End Stage) COPD
Example of explanation to patient
Thank you, Steve, for opening up about how things have been for you lately. I can hear how difficult it’s been, and I want to reassure you that I’m here to support you. From everything you’ve told me, it sounds like your COPD has reached a more advanced stage, what we medically refer to as ‘end-stage COPD’. I know that can sound worrying, but what this really means is that we now focus on making sure you’re as comfortable as possible, managing your symptoms, and helping you live well day to day. This approach is called palliative care, and it’s about improving your quality of life, not giving up, but shifting our focus to what matters most to you.
For your breathlessness, which I know is really affecting you, we can try a combination of simple non-medication and medication options. You might find that keeping the room cool, improving air circulation with a fan or an open window, can help ease your breathing. I’d also like to refer a physiotherapist who can visit you at home. They can teach you breathing techniques and guide you through light physical activities that are safe and tailored to your ability, nothing strenuous at all. Even small movements like standing briefly once an hour, or gentle leg exercises, can make a difference in how you feel over time.
On the medication side, we can look at switching your co-codamol to something called Oramorph, a liquid form of morphine taken in very small doses. It works quite quickly to ease the feeling of breathlessness, and can also help with pain, which I understand you were using co-codamol for, likely due to your arthritis and back pain — is that right?
We would start with a low dose a few times a day. If it helps, we can slowly adjust the dose to keep you comfortable. And if that’s not enough, there are other options we can explore, includingspeaking to a specialist about home oxygen, but only if you meet the criteria and your oxygen levels suggest it would help.
If you’re having trouble using your inhalers, which is quite common when you’re feeling weak or breathless, we can also consider a nebuliser — it’s a machine you may have used in hospital before that delivers medication as a mist, making it easier to breathe in.
I would also like to offer you and your wife a home visit to have a conversation about what you’d like going forward — this includes your preferences for care, where you’d feel most comfortable being looked after, and talking about things like resuscitation and what we call a ‘Ceiling of Treatment’. These discussions are called advance care planning, and they give you the chance to stay in control and make your wishes known for the future. That way, if there ever comes a time when you’re not in a position to make decisions for yourself, we can be confident we’re acting in line with what you want.
Because I can see your wife is already doing a lot to support you, and I imagine that’s not easy given her own health, I’ll ask our frailty team or occupational therapist to visit as well. They can look at what extra help might be needed at home, including carers or support services, and help you both feel less overwhelmed.
I’ll also fill in a form called an SR1 — this allows you to access some additional financial support quicker. Our social prescriber can then get in touch to talk you through any other benefits or support you’re entitled to.
Lastly, I’ll ask our clinical pharmacist to give you a call to go through your medications, to see if there’s anything we can stop or simplify so you’re not taking more than you need.
I’ll arrange to check in with you again in two weeks to see how everything is going, and of course, if anything worsens or you have concerns before then, please don’t wait. Just get in touch and we’ll do everything we can to help.
Management
- Acknowledge and validate the patient’s concerns. Gently explain that COPD is a progressive, long-term condition, and from what he has described, he appears to be in the advanced (end-stage) phase of the disease. The current goal of care is not to cure the condition, but to maximise comfort and quality of life through a palliative approach.
- Address breathlessness using both pharmacological and non-pharmacological strategies
- Non-pharmacological methods include advising the patient on simple measures to help relieve breathlessness, such as keeping the room cool, improving air circulation with a fan or open window. Refer to a physiotherapist who can offer home visits and support with breathing techniques and physical activity that is realistically achievable, which can help improve breathing, increase tolerance, and maintain fitness.
- Advise the patient that the physical activity from the physiotherapist will not be strenuous and will be tailored to his individual needs, especially as he is mostly bedbound. This may include simple movements such as standing up briefly once an hour.
- For pharmacological management, consider switching the patient from co-codamol to a low-dose oral morphine preparation, carefully titrated, to help reduce the sensation of breathlessness. Note that Opioids should be prescribed alongside regular laxatives and consideration of an anti-emetic to manage side effects.
- Consider a home nebuliser trial if symptoms remain poorly controlled or if the patient has difficulty using inhalers.
- Offer a trial of benzodiazepines if anxiety or agitation is contributing to breathlessness; choice of medication depends on the severity of anxiety, the desired onset of action, and the stage of terminal disease. Lorazepam may be used for acute relief (short-acting), diazepam for ongoing anxiety symptoms (longer-acting), and midazolam can be considered for intractable breathlessness, either as needed or via syringe driver in a palliative care setting.
- Advise the patient that if all the above measures do not adequately control his breathlessness, we can consider oxygen therapy — but this would require a referral to a specialist and would depend on whether he meets specific eligibility criteria.
- Offer home visit to discuss Advance Care Planning: to explore the patient’s values, preferences, and concerns regarding future care, discuss advance decisions, preferred place of care, ceiling of treatment options and DNACPR
- Refer to the frailty or occupational therapy team for a home assessment – to determine support that is needed,carer options or discussion for other care support needs as wife is struggling
- Advise that you will complete the SR1 form to support access to benefits and involve the social prescriber to explore additional supports and financial entitlements.
- Arrange a structured medication review with the clinical pharmacist to evaluate current medications, deprescribe where appropriate, and ensure the patient is not being overburdened by unnecessary treatments.
- Safety netting and advise if things get worse or if he has any concerns to seek urgent medical advise
- Follow up call in 2 weeks to see how everything is going
Learning point from this station:
There is no universally accepted definition of “end-stage COPD,” and predicting life expectancy in COPD remains challenging. Most patients experience a pattern of gradual functional decline with acute flare-ups that can increase the risk of dying. Tools such as those from the Gold Standards Framework can support healthcare professionals in identifying patients who are likely approaching the end of life.
The management of end-stage COPD focuses on palliative care, with an emphasis on symptom control.
For breathlessness — the most reported and distressing symptom. Both non-pharmacological and pharmacologicalstrategies should be considered.
Non-pharmacological measures include:
- Keeping the room cool and improving air circulation (e.g. using a fan or opening a window).
- Referral to a physiotherapist for home-based input on breathing control techniques, relaxation strategies, and light physical activity adapted to the patient’s capabilities. Even in bedbound patients, minimal movements (e.g. standing briefly or leg exercises) can improve tolerance and preserve function.
Pharmacological treatments:
- Opioids are first-line for refractory breathlessness. Immediate-release oral morphine is typically used, with subcutaneous morphine or diamorphine (via bolus or syringe driver) considered if oral administration is not feasible. Opioids should be prescribed alongside regular laxatives and consideration of an anti-emetic to manage side effects.
- Benzodiazepines can be offered if anxiety or agitation is contributing to breathlessness; choice of medication depends on the severity of anxiety, the desired onset of action, and the stage of terminal disease. Lorazepam may be used for acute relief (short-acting), diazepam for ongoing anxiety symptoms (longer-acting), and midazolam can be considered for intractable breathlessness, either as needed or via syringe driver in a palliative care setting.
- Home oxygen may be considered only after failure of other pharmacological approaches and in cases of symptomatic hypoxaemia (SpO₂ ≤ 92%). According to British Thoracic Society guidelines, oxygen may be beneficial if it raises SpO₂ above 92%, but hypoxaemia should ideally be confirmed with arterial or capillary blood gases. Given the practical difficulties of blood gas testing in palliative settings, NICE CKS recommends using clinical judgment supported by pulse oximetry and advice from respiratory or palliative care specialists to guide oxygen initiation.
Cough management depends on whether the cough is dry or moist
For dry cough:
- Start with simple, non-pharmacological measures such as humidifying the room air and trying Simple Linctus BP cough syrup. (Note: although called a cough syrup, Simple Linctus contains citric acid and is considered a symptomatic remedy rather than a true pharmacological treatment, as it does not contain any active drug that interacts with receptors or alters physiological processes in the body).
- If symptoms persist, consider a weak opioid cough suppressant (unless the patient is already on strong opioids for pain), such as Pholcodine linctus BP (10 mL [5–10 mg] three to four times daily), Codeine linctus BP (5–10 mL [15–30 mg] three to four times daily), or Codeine phosphate tablets (15–30 mg every 4 hours).
- If the cough remains persistent despite the use of weak opioids, switch to oral morphine every 4 hours and as needed. For opioid-naive patients, start at 1–2.5 mg every 4 hours; for those with prior opioid use, start at 2.5–5 mg every 4 hours.
For moist (productive) cough:
- If infection is suspected, treat with an appropriate broad-spectrum antibiotic.
- Consider nebulised saline to loosen tenacious secretions; this may be used in conjunction with physiotherapy to aid clearance.
- Use a mucolytic, such as carbocisteine, to reduce secretion viscosity. The recommended starting dose of carbocisteine is 750 mg three times a day. Review effectiveness after 4 weeks and stop if no benefit is seen.
- Consider humidifying air or oxygen in patients with dry mouth and persistent productive cough.
- In patients at the terminal stage who are unable to expectorate, reposition them to avoid lying supine; instead, place them on one side with the upper body elevated to promote postural drainage, and consider suctioning if available and appropriate.
- If non-pharmacological measures are ineffective, consider a trial of antisecretory agents to dry excessive secretions, such as Glycopyrronium bromide, Hyoscine butylbromide, or Hyoscine hydrobromide (with caution, as it may cause sedation or confusion).
- In cases where secretions remain problematic and the patient is too weak to cough effectively, morphine may also serve as a cough suppressant. However, cough suppressants should generally be avoided in moist cough, except in dying patients who are unable to expectorate and are experiencing distress or exhaustion.
Other common end-of-life symptoms include pain, insomnia, anxiety, and depression. These should be managed according to standard palliative care protocols.
Advance Care Planning remains central in this setting and should include discussions about the ceiling of care, DNACPR decisions, completion of the SR1 form, providing the patient with contact details for palliative care support, exploring future treatment preferences and goals, introducing anticipatory medications if appropriate, and coordinating with community teams, district nurses, carers, and family members to support comfort and dignity at home or in the patient’s preferred place of care.
https://cks.nice.org.uk/topics/chronic-obstructive-pulmonary-disease/management/end-stage-copd/
https://cks.nice.org.uk/topics/palliative-care-cough/
https://cks.nice.org.uk/topics/palliative-care-dyspnoea/